Creative Halloween Treat Bag Filler Ideas

Move beyond the typical candy-only approach with creative Halloween treat bag filler ideas that kids will actually enjoy!

Whether you’re assembling party favors, classroom treats, or trick-or-treat alternatives, these free printable gift tags add a personal touch that makes any small gift feel special.

Pair them with thoughtful non-candy items or homemade goodies for treat bags that stand out from the crowd.

Perfect for parents concerned about sugar overload, teachers managing classroom allergies, or anyone looking to create memorable Halloween treats, these ideas and printables help you assemble impressive goodie bags on any budget.

Creative Non-Candy Halloween Treat Bag Fillers

Toys and Trinkets:

Mini flashlights or glow sticks
Halloween erasers and pencils
Temporary tattoos
Small toy figurines
Bouncy balls
Stickers and sticker sheets

Creative Activities:

Mini coloring books
Halloween-themed activity pages
Small craft kits
Play-dough in Halloween colors
Bubbles in orange or black bottles

Practical Items:

Halloween socks
Hair accessories with festive designs
Small notebooks or journals
Bookmarks (pair with our free printables!)
Reusable snack bags with Halloween prints

Homemade Treats:

Individually wrapped cookies
Rice crispy treats
Trail mix in decorated bags
Caramel apples
Hot cocoa packets

Why Use Printable Halloween Gift Tags?

Personal Touch – Transform any item into a thoughtful gift with customized tags featuring recipient names
Professional Appearance – Well-designed tags make homemade or simple items look polished and intentional
Cost-Effective – Free printables save money compared to store-bought tags while offering more design variety
Allergy-Friendly Labeling – Clearly mark homemade treats with ingredients or indicate non-food items
Reusable Designs – Print exactly what you need when you need it, year after year
Variety of Styles – Choose from spooky designs for older kids or cute characters for younger children

How to Assemble Amazing Halloween Treat Bags

Download Gift Tags – Click the button below to get 12 different printable Halloween gift tag designs
Select Your Fillers – Choose 3-5 items per bag mixing toys, activities, and treats based on your budget
Print and Prepare Tags – Print tags on cardstock for durability, cut out, and add recipient names if personalizing
Assemble Bags – Use clear cellophane bags, small paper bags, or Halloween-printed bags as containers
Attach Tags Creatively – Use ribbon, twine, or baker’s string to tie tags onto bags for a finished look
Add Extra Touches – Consider tissue paper, shredded paper “grass,” or stickers to enhance presentation

Click the button below to download your free Halloween gift tags in 12 designs and start assembling your creative treat bags!